SIM-only or a phone contract: which costs less?
Updated 12 November 2026 · 3 minute read
The short answer
SIM-only is nearly always cheaper if you already have a phone you are happy with. Price-comparison research published in 2026 put the average saving from moving to SIM-only at about £300 a year.
Why the gap is so large
A phone contract bundles two things: the handset, paid off over two or three years, and the airtime. When the minimum term ends the handset is paid for, but many people carry on paying the same monthly price.
SIM-only plans are now half of all pay-monthly subscriptions in the UK, and prices for unlimited SIM-only plans have been falling.
Do the sum
- Add up every monthly payment on the phone contract, including any April rises.
- Find the price of the same phone bought outright, new or refurbished.
- Add a SIM-only plan with the allowance you need for the same number of months.
- Compare the two totals, not the monthly prices.
When a contract still makes sense
- You cannot or would rather not pay for the phone up front.
- The bundle is discounted below the handset's outright price, which does happen at launch and in sales.
This guide describes UK rules in general and is not legal advice. Rules change; the date above is when we last checked it against Ofcom's published guidance.